Which is harder shea butter or coconut oil – Comparison with Research Data 2023

Shea butter and coconut oil are being used for a long period. They are both incredibly well-liked beauty items. Which is harder shea butter or coconut oil? Which is better than the other? Which one will work best for you? So, read the rest of the blog for a satisfying response to this queries.

In regard to the hardness of shea butter and coconut oil, after usage, I felt shea butter is harder than coconut oil, when you compare the melting point of both butters you will understand that. I have explained this in detail at the end also for more confirmation I have also attached a video, You can watch it at the end.

Store-bought body lotions are bad for you

It’s incredibly reckless to merely spread body lotion all over our bodies without at least reviewing what is on its ingredient lists, given that our skin absorbs about 60% of what we apply. Unfortunately, a lot of us still partake in it. You can only imagine how many of the many chemicals used in personal care products—including petroleum, parabens, and synthetic fragrances—enter our bodies. This definitely hurts our bodies in some way.

People start understanding the negative side of the excessive use of chemicals. In today’s world, the environment is filled with chemicals, so as the products we use daily. 

Shea butter and Coconut oil

Where should you begin if you’re seeking a fantastic moisturizer that’s free of petroleum, parabens, and artificial perfumes but doesn’t want to spend a lot of money buying a lot of products to test out?

There is no deception involved with these methods—just one ingredient and no additives—and coconut oil and shea butter are two of the most well-known ways to naturally moisturize the skin.

If you are interested in cosmetics and general physiological well-being but are not a fan of organic beauty products, then you may have also wondered which product would be best for your daily use cosmetics or even your culinary activities in this coconut oil versus shea butter debate.

Shea Butter Overview

The sun-dried kernels of the Vitellaria paradoxa Shea tree are used to make shea butter, a type of vegetable fat. Tropical Africa’s east and west are home to the Shea tree.

Two oily kernels found inside the Shea tree seed are where the shea butter is found. The kernel is separated from the seed, powdered, and then cooked in water. The butter then solidifies and floats to the top of the water.

Shea butter is applied topically to treat a variety of skin issues, including eczema, burns, dandruff, dry skin, and acne. Shea butter is used in food as a cooking fat and is also used in the production of cosmetics.

Benefits of Shea butter

Shea butter is beneficial in many ways, let’s see one by one

Benefits of shea butter for skin:

Shea butter is like food for the skin, did you know that? It contains vitamins A, E, and F which are essential for healthy skin. All three vitamins, especially vitamin F, soothe dry, chapped, or rough skin and aid in the healing process. Vitamin A promotes healthy skin.

It functions as an emollient and skin moisturizer, and it offers sun protection qualities.

Triterpenes, which are present in shea butter, have anti-inflammatory and antioxidant characteristics.

Linoleic acid is also present in shea butter. A Study in 2018 found that Linoleic acid-containing products have qualities that reduced skin inflammation and increased moisture.

Benefits of shea butter on hair:

Shea butter contains 6-17%non-saponifiable (non-soap forming) lipid (NSL). The NSL fraction of the oil is where the majority of the bioactive compounds in oils that confer beneficial functional qualities, including as moisturizing, conditioning, anti-inflammatory, and antioxidant activity, are concentrated.

Shea butter’s hydrating and anti-inflammatory qualities may help lessen dry scalp and irritated scalp.

Shea butter does not distribute as quickly through hair as oils do, so Shea oil may be better for hair in the long run. Shea butter should be left on the hair before being washed off in the shower with a gentle shampoo.

Shea butter or Shea oil should not be used to hair if it is prone to become greasy, since this could aggravate the issue.

Other generalized benefits and uses of Shea Butter

  • skin sores.
  • sun-induced creases on the skin.
  • stretch stains
  • swelling (inflammation) of the sinuses and nasal cavities (rhinosinusitis).
  • wound recovery.
  • dry skin
  • Rash.
  • Itchy, scaly skin (psoriasis).
  • Scarring.
  • elevated blood pressure
  • insect sting.
  • Itching.
  • itchiness brought on by a mite infection (scabies).
  • muscle aches.
  • Osteoarthritis.

Coconut Oil Overview

Many South Asian diets include coconut oil as a staple. At first, coconut oil was deemed to have a detrimental effect on health and was grouped with foods high in saturated fatty acids. However, studies have shown that medium-chain fatty acids are abundant in coconut oil. This has therefore created fresh opportunities for its usage in numerous industries.

In addition to being used in cooking, coconut oil is noteworthy for its hypocholesterolemic, anticancer, anti-hepatosteatotic, anti-diabetic, antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, anti-microbial, and skin-moisturizing characteristics.

The flesh of a mature coconut called ‘copra’ is stripped and dried coconut flesh. With a specialized machine extractor or press, copra is pressed and extracted the oil known as coconut oil.

The oil can be extracted using a variety of techniques, but regardless of the technique, it is best to avoid oil that has been refined, bleached, or deodorized because these procedures lessen the health advantages as well as the flavor and aroma of the coconut oil.

Coconut oil is utilized as a herbicide, a cooking ingredient, and even for skin treatment.

Benefits of Coconut Oil

Health benefits of coconut oil

  • Research suggests that coconut oil improves the balance of cholesterol levels in the blood. It also seems to protect arteries by reducing injury and clogging
  • Due to its ease of digestion and rapid burning, coconut oil may even aid in weight loss.
  • Antiviral, antibacterial, and antifungal activities are all found in coconut oil. This indicates that it improves immune defense and lowers infection susceptibility.

Coconut oil for skin benefits

Due to its anti-inflammatory characteristics, coconut oil is beneficial for many various types of skin conditions, including eczema, psoriasis, and contact dermatitis.

Coconut oil for face

Using coconut oil as an overnight moisturizer can be beneficial for people with very dry, chafed, or flaky skin. However, due to its high comedogenic rating, coconut oil may pose serious issues for anyone with sensitive or acne-prone skin. Because it lies on top of the skin, coconut oil can’t penetrate the pores, which means it might potentially smother your skin and clog your pores.

Coconut oil for hair

The best oil to put on your hair to prevent protein loss and maintain its health is frequently cited as coconut oil. When used either before or after washing the hair, coconut oil was found to be more effective at preventing protein loss than both mineral oil and sunflower oil.

In research experiments, coconut oil really outperformed the competition and slowed down protein loss in unharmed, bleached, chemically treated, and UV-exposed hair.

Which is the better moisturizer for skin coconut oil or shea butter?

Shea butter and coconut oil are both excellent substances used for a variety of cosmetic purposes and to treat illnesses. However, while deciding which one to use for your skin, there is one key difference.

All skin types can safely use shea butter. Therefore, it won’t bother your skin if you have dry or oily skin. Additionally, shea butter calms the skin and lessens inflammation.

Although coconut oil is fatty, it does offer antibacterial (reduces mould) qualities that can be useful. This implies that having oily skin may result in breakouts. When coconut oil accumulates and blocks pores, it might result in problems.

Which is harder shea butter or coconut oil?

The melting point of Shea butter is 37° Celsius, and for coconut butter it is 26° Celsius. As per my experience, Shea butter is comparatively harder than coconut oil, It is sticky, which is good for extremely dry skin.

On the other hand, Coconut butter melts when applied to the skin. It can be applied smoothly and is good for mild oily skin.

To find out the harder one I have attached a video here.


Coconut Oil and Shea Butter are both superb moisturizers. One can use Shea butter and coconut oil interchangeably without detecting any difference. Both naturally occurring vegan fats have many advantages for our health and appearance.

Our own needs and how well one of them serves them to determine which of the two we choose. In the same way that you should consult your dermatologist before using any of these in your skincare routine, regardless of how organic they are, and regardless of whether you should use them in cooking, your general physician should be the final to make assumptions based on your health state.

Mr.Viju V
Follow me

Leave a Comment